Business SystemsGuide

Our Google Impressions Rose 44% and Our Average Position Fell From 36 to 63. Nothing Was Wrong.

Average position is an average over every time Google showed you, so new pages that appear on page seven pull it down even when nothing you ranked for before has moved. Before you react to a falling number, split it by page.

Author

DueClix Engineering

Published

Reading time

3 min read

Our weekly check on 18 November showed two numbers moving in opposite directions. Google showed dueclix.com 44% more often than the week before: 1,669 impressions against 1,161. In the same week our average position fell from about 36 to about 63.

Read quickly, that is a warning: we are being shown more, but lower, so something must have dropped. It is the kind of chart that leads people to rewrite pages or blame an update. In our case nothing had dropped at all.

Why the average can fall when nothing got worse

Average position in Search Console is an average over every impression, weighted by how often each page was shown. If a page you already rank for sits at position 3 and Google starts showing ten new pages of yours at position 75, the average falls sharply. The page at position 3 has not moved.

So a falling average can mean two very different things: pages you had are slipping, or new pages are entering low. The second is usually good news. The only way to know which is to look one level down.

What our numbers showed, one level down

We switched the Performance report to the Pages tab for the last seven days and added up impressions by section and by position band:

dueclix.com, Search Console, 7 days to 16 November 2026
MeasureImpressions
All pages (821 pages shown at least once)1,783
Directory listing pages1,708 (96%)
Shown at position 50 or lower1,031 (58%)
Shown in the top 20599
Insights articles9
Free tool pages1

The rise came almost entirely from business listings in our directory, many of them shown for the first time, for broad local searches such as a trade plus a city. The biggest riser was a mechanic's listing shown 65 times at an average position of 76. Our homepage stayed at position 1.9, and the pages that already earned clicks kept their positions.

A ten-minute check before you react

  1. Open Performance, then the Pages tab, for the last 7 days, with Impressions and Position both ticked.
  2. Sort by impressions and look at the top 20. Are they pages you know, or pages you have never seen in this report before?
  3. Compare with the previous 7 days (Date → Compare). Pages marked as new with positions above 50 are pages entering, not pages falling.
  4. Check the pages that earn clicks. Filter to the ten pages with the most clicks over 28 days. If their positions held, nothing you rely on has been lost.
  5. Only then look at queries. A broad query like a single trade word at position 70 is Google testing you, not a ranking you lost.

When it is a real drop

The picture is different when the same pages show worse positions than the week before, when clicks fall while impressions hold, or when the change starts on one day across the whole site. That is the pattern worth investigating, and our checklist for a sudden Google traffic drop covers what to look at first.

What we are doing with it

  • Nothing drastic. New pages appearing on page seven is the step before page one, not a problem to fix.
  • Watching clicks, not the average. Clicks for the week were 12 against 10. That is the number that has to move.
  • Noting the gap. 96% of our impressions come from the directory, and our free tools and articles are barely shown yet. That tells us where the next work goes.

If a Search Console chart has you worried, send us the screenshot. We will tell you whether it is a drop or an average doing what averages do.

Written by

DueClix EngineeringEngineering team

The team that designs and builds DueClix systems. We write about the parts of the work that are worth writing down.

Have a process worth improving?

Let's build the system behind it. Tell us what the process is and where it breaks — the first conversation is about constraints, not technology.